Cookies & Baked Goods
  • $9.50
    Island Bakery Organics is a small family-run business from Tobermory on the Hebridean Isle of Mull. There they make...
  • Island Bakery Lemon Melts

    5 Stars
    (2 Reviews)
    $9.50
    These irresistible cookies get their extraordinary flavor from pure Sicilian lemon oil. The recipe is simple and the...
    Qty.
  • $31.00
    Spoil your family and friends with this generous selection of handmade shortbread from Shortbread House, a small,...
    Qty.
  • $7.99
    Based in Edinburgh, Scotland, The Shortbread House is known throughout the British Isles for its premier shortbread....
    Qty.
  • $8.99
    Winner of an unprecedented 12 Great Taste Awards, this is shortbread without shortcuts. The crisp, crumbly texture...
    Qty.
  • $10.00
    These beautiful boxes contain approximately 16 mini shortbread biscuits and make a lovely small gift or a special...
    Qty.
  • $7.60
    Look out, lemon lovers. This is the cookie for you! Slightly tart from the bright taste of lemon and slightly sweet...
    Qty.
  • Key Lime Cookies

    5 Stars
    (1 Review)
    $7.60
    This slightly tart tea cookie is inspired by Florida's signature fruit, the key lime, and gets a hint of sweet from a...
    Qty.
  • $27.50
    From celebrated blogger Sarah Kieffer of The Vanilla Bean Baking Blog, 100 Cookies is a go-to baking book...
    Qty.
  • $9.25–$9.50
    Authentic, artisan style biscotti - a delicious, edible gift! Gilda Doganiero, a... 
  • $15.50
    Fresh, smooth and bright, the taste of real peppermint has been lost for generations. Until now. Summerdown...
    Qty.
  • Cinnamon Walnut Coffee Cake

    5 Stars
    (1 Review)
    $2.95–$25.99
    A deliciously sweet way to start your day! Our unbelievably moist Cinnamon Walnut Coffee Cake is baked to order from...

Do we have cookies! Gourmet cookies, shortbread cookies, holiday cookies--and books full of cookie recipes. Our scrumptious selection comes from sourcing the best in small batch, artisan produced cookies: the best of the best. For Christmas gifts and entertaining we have a wide selection of beautiful tins filled with your favorites, from biscotti to stem ginger, to a gorgeous shortbread assortment. If you're in the mood to try something different we've got flavored shortbread cookies including Macademia Nut, Sicilian Lemon, and Famous Grouse Whiskey, each unique and delicious. J & M's Holiday Spice Cookies rolled in powdered sugar are a favorite at the Savory Pantry; they come in a beautifully designed tin and make a lovely host or hostess gift.

Christmas Cookies get the royal treatment from Rustic Bakery with intricately designed Gingerbread Tile Cookies (big enough to share), Ginger Babies (cute as a button), and Vanilla Snowflake Cookies (packed in a glass jar). And we have a nice assortment of speculoos, the spiced shortcrust biscuit traditionally baked on or just before St Nicholas' day in the Netherlands, Belgium, Luxembourg, and around Christmas in Germany and Austria. They're thin, crunchy, caramelized, and stamped on the front side before baking, now making them a favorite holiday cookie worldwide.

If you're baking your own, may we suggest two baking books? 100 Cookies and Cookie Perfection are both excellent choices for making gourmet cookies right at home. Filed with beautiful photography and well-tested recipes, they make nice gifts for home bakers, too.

Welcome to Savory Pantry

At Your Service

We are your gourmet concierge, standing by to create tasty, memorable food gifts for anyone and everyone on your list -- including you! No order or budget too big or too small.
Give us a ring: 877-426-4887.